Logo
About UsFAQ's

2007 Savings By Design Energy Efficiency Integration Awards
   

2007 Savings By Design Energy Efficiency Integration Award Winners

Awards of Honor

Awards of Merit

Citations

Distinguished Jurors

 
Previous Award Winners
 
Awards sponsored by:
American Institute of Architects
PG&E
Sacramento Municipal Utility District
SDGE A Sempra Energy Utility
So Cal Edison
So Cal Gas Co.

    

 

 

 

 

For their achievement in combining exceptional design, environmental sensitivity, and energy efficiency, seven California nonresidential projects received awards of recognition from the 2007 Savings By Design Energy Efficiency Integration Awards program.

Every year, the recognition program, sponsored by Pacific Gas and Electric Company, San Diego Gas & Electric®, Southern California Edison, Southern California Gas Company, Sacramento Municipal Utility District, and The American Institute of Architects, California Council (AIACC), acknowledges the extra time and effort it takes to successfully integrate architectural excellence and energy efficiency.

The jurors agreed that the highly inventive solutions represented by the winners would be instructive to other designers in California and throughout the nation.


Award of Honor:
California Public Employees Retirement System (CalPERS) Headquarters Complex


Owner/Developer: California Public Employees Retirement System
Architect: Pickard Chilton
Design Team: Kendall/Heaton Associates Inc., CYS Structural Engineers Inc., Ove Arup and Partners, Hart/Howerton, Interior Architects Inc., Simon & Associates Inc., and Hensel Phelps Construction Company

Dusk view looking West with sculptural entrance pavilion at left.

Credit: Peter Aaron/Esto Photographics (Click to enlarge)

The CalPERS building offers office and retail space, proposed housing, and two levels of below-grade parking. The building has successfully responded to the city's urban fabric as well as the client's sustainable design goals. Its careful planning and construction allowed the building to perform 28% better than Title 24 minimum standards and attain LEED® Gold certification.

Landscaped public courtyard with fountain and exterior walkways beyond.

Credit: Peter Aaron/Esto Photographics (Click to enlarge)

The high expectations of their client motivated the entire team to participate in green building workshops early in the design process. Through these workshops, the team was able to prioritize the green strategies for the project and reach the client's goals for their large-scale headquarters.

View of day lit open interior atrium at core of building.

Credit: Peter Aaron/Esto Photographics (Click to enlarge)

A large focus was put on the building's use of natural light. Shading projections, light shelves, floor-to-ceiling glass and integrated planters allow for a reduction in electric lighting. The building is also broken up by a courtyard and atrium-- two aspects that the jurors agreed made the building a "great place to work." The jurors also noted that CalPERS was the only winning entrant that utilized underfloor air distribution, helping to reduce the cooling energy requirements of the building. The project's high levels of energy efficiency and unique architecture made it a highly appropriate choice as winner of the honor award.


Back to Top


Award of Merit:
UC Merced Library and Information Technology Center


Owner: University of California Merced Physical Planning Design & Construction
Architect: Skidmore, Owings & Merrill LLP
Design Team: Fernau and Hartman, Peter Walker & Partners, and Swinerton Inc.

Credit: Tim Griffith (Click to enlarge)

The UC Merced Library and Information Technology Center is both a work of art and a functional and efficient structure. The broad arcades, louvers and overhangs of the building allow shade while still maximizing the amount of daylighting and keeping a close connection with the outdoors.

Credit: Tim Griffith (Click to enlarge)

The 46,000 ft 2 building is also equipped with advanced computerized heating, cooling and lighting systems to reduce power needs and monitor data. Seventy-six percent of the construction waste created was diverted from landfills and approximately 45% of materials used contain recycled content. Sustainable practices earned the library a LEEDoo Gold rating.

The library is designed to allow students and faculty to access its high tech features, such as WiFi. This allows students with laptops to study in a wider variety of spaces and enjoy the open feel of the building. Due to the Central Valley's hot climate, sun mitigation strategies, such as orientation, had to be devised and landscaping had to be designed accordingly.

Credit: Tim Griffith (Click to enlarge)

The jurors praised the entry for its effective shading and its high-energy savings of over 30% by California Title 24 standards. They also mentioned the modernity and beauty of the building's lantern reading room and its use of light, appearing to make the room "sparkle."


Award of Merit:
Arastradero Preserve Gateway Facility


Owner: City of Palo Alto, CA
Architect: Arkin Tilt Architects
Design Team: Toft, DeNevers & Lee, Acterra, John M. Cruikshank Consultants Inc., Alpha Consulting Group, A&A Construction

Overall view from the parking lot to the west.

Credit: Edward Caldwell (Click to enlarge)

This 622-acre preserve, located on the outskirts of Palo Alto, is a popular destination for hiking, mountain biking, and horseback riding. The restoration of this preserve habitat was made possible primarily with volunteer labor through partnerships with the local land stewards. The emphasis of this restoration was on minimizing ecological impact, which was achieved through its small size, the use of natural materials, and energy independence.

South elevation of office and equestrian traffic.

Credit: Edward Caldwell (Click to enlarge)

By utilizing methods of passive solar design with seasonally adjustable solar panels, the facility is able to run completely off the grid. Jurors praised the adjustable panels for their originality and cleverness. Due to it being powered with renewable energy, the preserve was not subject to Title 24 standards. However, the facility only uses 25% of the base case.

Interior view of the barn-like main building with straw bale wall to north and exposed framing.

Credit: Edward Caldwell (Click to enlarge)

Fluorescent and low-voltage lighting are minimal and the design of the stand-alone building allows for room expansion through the use of sliding barn doors. Using straw-bale and recycled timber construction, the building contains no mechanical system, making zero energy use inherent. The jurors found the building to be deserving of the merit award based on the effective restoration and the zero energy use of the building. They found the 1,200 ft 2 building to be both elegant and modest.

Back to Top


Citation:
Molecular Foundry, Berkeley


Owner: Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory
Architect: SmithGroup, Inc.
Design Team: Rutherford + Chekene, Peter Walker Associates, Gayner Engineering, Rudolph + Sletten

South Façade

Credit: David Wakely (Click to enlarge)

The 95,692 ft 2 Molecular Foundry was created to symbolize the advanced nature of nanoscience research and is a testament to modern technology. Built on a steep site between two existing buildings, the facility's energy consumption was reduced by over 27% relative to Title 24 energy standards. Although the building currently earns a LEED Silver rating, it is now on track to achieve Gold. This high performance was accomplished through water efficiency, energy performance, materials and resources, and indoor environmental quality.

To help minimize development impact on nocturnal environments, exterior and interior lighting was designed not to disturb the night sky.

Credit: David Wakely (Click to enlarge)

Located on 2.5 acres, fifty percent of the site was restored with native grasses and wildflowers, requiring no irrigation system. The site also has good access to public transportation, encouraging its occupants to make the commute by alternative means. The laboratories are flexible modules, often with no fixed casework. This allows for reduced waste generation and resource expenditures in future renovations.

The energy efficiency measures used for the building include high-efficiency modulating and condensing boilers, lower air handler filter and coil air flow face velocities, and electronic filters for lower pressure drop. Spectrally selective window coatings and clerestory windows allow for the abundance of natural light in nonperimeter spaces.

This south- and west-facing deck uses drought-resistant plants and offers dramatic views over Strawberry Canyon, the UC Berkeley campus and to the City of San Francisco.

Credit: David Wakely (Click to enlarge)

The jurors mentioned the good usage of daylighting and the proper orientation of the building. They were also impressed by the ability of the designers to examine the loads of the building and reduce the chilled water capacity of the labs dramatically. To ensure that mechanical and electrical systems were the right size, the client measured the loads of three other campus laboratories to obtain a more accurate characterization of end-use loads.


Citation:
United States Federal Building, San Francisco


Owner: U.S. General Services Administration
Architect: Morphosis Architects
Design Team: Smith Group Inc., Ove Arup and Partners, Richard Haag Associates Inc., J.J.R., Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, Brian Kangas Foulk, Dick Corporation, Morganti General Contractors

Exterior View (Public Plaza)

Credit: Tim Griffith (Click to enlarge)

The San Francisco Federal Building is a testament to design excellence and sustainable architecture. The building is meant to serve the tenants and the community and does so with the highest design aspirations and innovative technology. The 18-story project houses a healthy work environment as well as resources for public use, such as a café, a childcare center, and a conference center.

Exterior View (Northwest Façade)

Credit: Morphosis (Click to enlarge)

The 605,000 ft 2 project offers a comfortable, health- and productivity-conscious work environment. With features like the skip-stop elevators, which stop at every third floor, and the cafeteria being placed across the plaza, the building encourages its occupants to move around and stay productive. The building also consists of a sky garden and a 90-foot high entry lobby to provide comfortable settings for both informal meetings and social interaction.

The building is currently experiencing approximately 11% better than Title 24 requirements. Daylighting is a huge factor in this energy savings with 85% of all workspace illuminated with natural light. The building incorporates building materials and construction strategies that minimize waste and energy consumption. The GSA mandated that 75% of materials used during construction be recycled. However, the project recycled 87% of its waste material.

Exterior View (Detail)

Credit: Tim Griffith (Click to enlarge)

The jurors praised the design team's ambition in the integration of new systems including a naturally ventilated office tower. The building achieves originality and energy-efficiency by being the first naturally ventilated office tower in the country. The natural light and shading was also a highpoint that jurors found exceptional.

Back to Top



Distinguished Jurors

Charles Eley, FAIA, PE
Vice-President, Architectural Energy Corporation

Mr. Eley is an architect and mechanical engineer with about 25 years experience in energy efficient and sustainable design. Mr. Eley has made significant contributions to the California energy standards, ASHRAE Standard 90.1, and energy codes in Hong Kong, Hawaii, Guam, American Samoa and Australia. Mr. Eley is now working with the California Energy Commission to update the state energy efficiency standards in response to the recent electricity crisis.

In addition to his energy codes and policy work, Mr. Eley has also developed a number of important publications including the Advanced Lighting Guidelines, the Lighting Fundamentals Handbook, and numerous other technical manuals on energy efficient and code compliance. Mr. Eley is the primary author and technical editor of the ASHRAE/IESNA Standard 90.1-1999 User's Manual. He is also the executive director of the Collaborative for High Performance Schools and is the technical editor of the CHPS Best Practices Manual.

Mr. Eley consults with other architects and engineers in the design of landmark energy efficient buildings. He also directs the software development team within Architectural Energy Corporation, which is responsible for VisualDOE, EnvStd, and a number of other computer programs for the energy efficient design of buildings.

 

Jack A. Paddon, AIA
Williams + Paddon Architects + Planners, Inc.

In 1981 Jack joined Jim Williams to establish Williams + Paddon Architects + Planners, Inc. Since that time, the firm has won the continued respect of clients and the communities they serve through many successfully completed projects.

Jack's leadership in Client Focused Design has guided almost two decades of value enhanced services for Williams + Paddon's many clients. Under his direction, the firm has become recognized as a leader in innovative design with an emphasis on regionally influenced sustainable projects for public and corporate clients.

Jack is a LEED Accredited Professional since 2002. Consistent with the firm's core values, he continues to volunteer his time to community and professional groups. Jack has served on the AIACC State Board of Directors, and served a term as president of the AIA Central Valley. He serves in multiple capacities in support of the California Board of Architectural Examiners.

Scott Shell, AIA, LEED® A.P.
Principal for EHDD Architecture
San Francisco, Calif.

Mr. Shell is a nationally recognized expert on high-performance buildings and sustainable design and has written and lectured widely on these topics. He has designed a number of EHDD's most successful, sustainable design projects, including the award-winning Global Ecology Research Center for the Carnegie Institution of Washington on the Stanford University campus and the recently completed Chartwell School in Monterey, which is anticipating a LEED Platinum rating.

Mr. Shell emphasizes an interdisciplinary approach to creating new models of sustainable design, focusing on low-energy and carbon-neutral buildings. He is currently working on the Lifecycle Building Challenge, using recovered building materials and Design for Deconstruction (DfD) to reduce building material impacts over the life of a building. Concurrently, he is working with his colleagues to make EHDD a model sustainable community and architectural practice.

Mr. Shell holds a Bachelor of Architecture degree from Auburn University and a Master of Arts in Humanities from Stanford University and studied Tamil language and culture at the University of Chicago and the American Institute of Indian Studies in Madurai.


Back to Top